Court of Appeal upholds judgment in favor of Staðarfjall ehf.

The Icelandic Court of Appeal (Landsréttur) recently upheld the judgment of the Reykjavík District Court in case no. 728/2025, Litlaland ehf. v. Staðarfjall ehf. Litlaland was ordered to pay ISK 33.5 million to Staðarfjall in contractual daily penalties due to a substantial delay in the delivery of real property, and the attachment of the company's assets was also upheld.
Among the issues considered in the case was when contractually agreed daily penalties become due and payable. The Court concluded that the right to such penalties accrues on each day that the delay in delivery continues, and that a seller cannot defer settlement of those penalties until final settlement where it is the seller’s own breach that prevents final settlement from taking place. The purchaser was furthermore entitled to withhold its own performance until the agreed delivery had occurred.
Jonsson & Hall represented Staðarfjall ehf. Einar Þór Sverrisson, attorney-at-law, argued the case on behalf of the company before both levels of court.


